Mining’s old guard needs strong medicine
A new report details subpar investor returns in the mining industry over the last decade, particularly big cap diversified companies which have not adapted to new realities.
A year after Canada tightened foreign investment rules for the critical minerals sector, Chinese money has continued to pour into Toronto-listed miners, according to proprietary research conducted by the University of Alberta.
The inbound flow is raising hopes among some junior miners that it will be easier to find Chinese funding.
Canada had forced three Chinese investors to sell their stakes in Canadian critical mineral companies in 2022. Some of these companies did not have their mines in Canada.
In October 2022, the government added an extra layer of scrutiny for inbound deals in critical minerals.
The changes did not specify which country’s investments would be scrutinized, but the government says it wants to secure the critical minerals sector, which is strategic to Canada’s national security.
Still, Canada’s critical miners received at least a dozen investments worth C$2.2 billion ($1.6 billion) in 2023 from new and existing investors in China and Hong Kong, a huge increase over C$62 million in 2022, data compiled by the University of Alberta’s The China Institute shows.
“What you are seeing is the reality, that there is no blockade of Chinese investments in Canada… it is a perception issue,” said Dean McPherson, head of mining, TMX Group Ltd.
“Chinese investors are not shy to risk, they are willing to stick in and ride it out (in Canada),” Mcpherson added.
Daniel Lincoln, a researcher with The China Institute, told Reuters Canada may find it difficult to regulate all Chinese mining acquisitions notwithstanding the provisions in the Investment Canada Act, especially when both buyer and seller are keen for the transaction.
In a latest test of Canada’s new rules, China’s state-owned Zijin Mining Group last month offered to buy a 15% stake in Solaris Resources Inc for C$130 million.
While Canada lists copper as a critical mineral, the deal is likely to be approved since the funds will be used to develop Solaris’ copper-gold project in Ecuador, two sources familiar with the deal told Reuters.
Solaris and Zijin did not respond to an email query by Reuters.
A spokesperson for the Ministry for Innovation, Science and Industry declined to comment on the Zijin deal, but said the government must examine each investment on its merit to ensure Canada remains open to necessary foreign direct investment.
Chinese investors have been among the most active in Canada’s mining industry, plowing C$21 billion between 1993 and 2023, according to data from The China Institute.
Last year, copper companies were the most targeted by Chinese investors. MMG Africa Ventures, a unit of state-backed China Minmetals Corp, bought a copper mine from Vancouver-based Cuprous Capital Ltd for C$1.7 billion, and Hong Kong-based Greenwater invested C$13 million in Gowest Gold, the data shows.
Jiangxi Copper Co Ltd increased its stake in First Quantum Minerals Ltd to 18.5% from 18.3% and the Chinese company also bought $20 million worth of senior notes in the Canadian company last year, regulatory filings show.
Some smaller miners and explorers have been lobbying the Canadian government to allow more Chinese investments, citing difficulty in raising capital.
On Sunday, Chinese miner Yintai Gold agreed to buy Vancouver-based Osino Resources for C$368 million. Osino and Yintai did not respond to a Reuters query about if they are seeking Canadian government approval for the deal. Gold is not considered a critical metal by Canada.
Michelle DeCecco, chief operating officer of Lithium Chile, one of the three companies that Canada ordered to get rid of its Chinese investor, told Reuters there was no softening in Ottawa’s stance because of which companies are finding alternative ways to secure Chinese funding.
Soon after SRG Mining Inc received a C$16.9 million investment proposal from C-ONE, backed by Chinese entrepreneur Yue Min, the Montreal-based graphite miner announced plans to change the country where it is incorporated. On Monday, it said it would incorporate in Abu Dhabi Global Markets while maintaining its Canadian stock market listing.
SRG Mining did not respond to an email query by Reuters.
“Unfortunately, it is often to take their companies out of Canada; away from Five Eyes,” DeCecco said, referring to the intelligence sharing network comprising of the United States, Britain, Canada, Australia and New Zealand.
($1 = 1.3522 Canadian dollars)
(By Divya Rajagopal and Julie Zhu; Editing by Denny Thomas and David Gregorio)
2 Comments
vernon emary
There you have it folks!….canada’s strategic minerals strategy, is nothing but a joke!…..Trudeau…proof that artificial inteligence is real!
Jacob Hunt
So, Canada is saying to junior miners, we wont help you, and will continue to allow environmentally unfriendly minerals from China, but you cant get money from China. The green revolution is a joke!!!