How to put the “engage” back into community engagement
Three techniques to help guide your interactions with unreceptive stakeholders
No matter what industry you’re in, putting in the extra effort to truly engage with your stakeholders will serve you well.
Author Janeth Pizarro
When you think of the practice of mining, communities may not be the first thing that comes to mind. But communities are an integral part of what we do. As we all know, mining activities are not conducted in a bubble. They have the potential to deeply impact the environment and surrounding communities, for better or worse. Unfortunately, we’ve been hearing more about the “worse” aspect in the media as reports show that mining protests have become increasingly common in the developed world. The reasons behind many of these protests are varied and complex, and there’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. But there is a way to start a job off on the right foot and reduce the likelihood of social conflict: extensive community engagement.
We saw the results of an effective community engagement program when we took on an Environmental Impact Assessment in preparation for a mining project in the northern region of Peru. This area has been the site for some mining-related incidents in the past that have negatively impacted the locals and the environment.
As a result, anti-mining sentiments have grown steadily stronger among the Peruvian residents over the years, and extensive protests had the power to bring multibillion-dollar projects in the region to a halt. When our team arrived, we faced the challenge of navigating a minefield of mistrust and resentment among the community.
How to change up the formula
In Peru, traditional approaches to community engagement had been two-fold: hold one or two large community meetings with members from the various towns surrounding the mine and give money to the communities to mitigate any potential damages caused by mining activities (a common conflict resolution tactic in Latin America). But the level of antagonism towards mining was so deep among Peru’s residents that these methods weren’t going to be sufficient. If you find your own community engagement program to be similarly ineffective, consider the following techniques:
- Focus on the individual:
Instead of holding large, catch-all community meetings, host multiple, smaller gatherings to prioritize building individual relationships. You will gain a much deeper understanding of the various concerns and priorities of your stakeholders. Smaller settings also tend to make people feel more comfortable expressing their opinions. To reach each of the approximately 50 towns that surround the mine, we created about 20 small focus groups that were attended by almost 600 people in total and conducted one-on-one interviews with about 300 individuals. Then, we simply listened to their doubts, fears, and concerns, and made every effort to address each one. We also collected demographic information from each town to help us identify future opportunities for community development.
- Make them participants:
The feeling of inclusion is a powerfully positive force. Wherever possible, make an effort to involve the community directly in the work you’re conducting. We brought approximately 2,000 community members into the field alongside our specialists to participate in the process of monitoring water, air, sound, and vibrations, where they were able to learn how the equipment works and how the procedures are completed. This led to increased transparency, as the residents saw exactly what we were doing during all stages and were given a hands-on opportunity to learn how our work related to the overall mining project.
- Don’t just tell; show:
When you have to describe a complex idea or process, words can only take you so far. Ninety percent of the information that is transmitted to our brains is visual; but visual information isn’t necessarily restricted to pictures. Here’s your chance to get creative. In Peru, we hosted more than 50 community workshops to explain the project scope but found that flat maps and 2D images did little to aid their understanding. So, we brought another dimension into the mix. Our team created physical models of the mine that allowed people to interact with the project in a tangible way and made a 3D video for everyone to view the planned layout and activities. The feedback regarding these learning techniques was overwhelmingly positive.
No matter what industry you’re in, putting in the extra effort to truly engage with your stakeholders will serve you well. It’s a risk avoidance technique that saves time and money in the long-run, but it also builds trust for future projects of a similar nature. Most importantly, it speaks to what you, and the company you represent, truly value. I hope it is always your priority to design with community in mind.