Mining’s old guard needs strong medicine
A new report details subpar investor returns in the mining industry over the last decade, particularly big cap diversified companies which have not adapted to new realities.
Base metals should continue to do well in 2018 along with the US steel industry, though American coal will continue to lose ground to natural gas.
These are the key conclusions of Moody’s Investor Service, which released a recent report summarizing commentary from analysts at a Jan. 18 teleconference.
Probably the most positive aspects of the report, with the least conditions attached, relate to base metals. According to Moody’s, the recovery in base metals that began in 2016 and gained momentum in 2017, spurred by global economic growth, is likely to continue this year, driven by China which holds sway as a major base metals importer and exporter. However Moody’s points out that Chinese growth in 2018 is expected to slip to 6.6% from 6.9% in 2017, due to a slowing of stimulus measures that propelled infrastructure and property investment last year. Still, it expects that stronger Purchasing Managers’ Indices (PMIs) will remain strong in other economies, “providing better support to the market fundamentals than has been seen over the last several years.” In other words, base metals prices should remain strong. Moody’s gives a nice summary of what occurred within the base metals complex in 2017 and the factors that are driving prices up:
Prices rose across almost all the metals in 2017, as each responded to specific drivers including labor disruptions, mine closures and capacity curtailments in China, and legislative changes in other countries. This, in conjunction with actions such as reducing capital expenditures and dividends, enabled the industry to repair and strengthen balance sheets by materially reducing the amount of debt in the capital structure after years of excessive spending and value destruction.
Emerging mega trends, such as the increase in demand for copper, nickel, lithium, and cobalt tied to expected increases in production of electric vehicles, is also driving some of the current price momentum. Reduced investment in mined production over the past few years has led to a potential deficit in some of these metals, and meeting expected demand appears to present a challenge.
With respect to the US steel industry, Moody’s pointed out that higher drill rig counts created better demand for steel drill pipe producers such as US Steel Corp. – which allowed the company to almost break even in Q4 2017. Construction markets also grew steadily although margins for long producers of rebar were compressed by high imports. Demand for steel in autos is expected to be solid in 2018, while the piping and tubing sector should see better prices. Hot rolled coil steel prices have risen in 2018 to around $740 a ton from an average $620 in 2017. But a confluence of factors including China restarting steel mills idled in the winter, has Moody’s lowering the price range to between $650 and $700 per ton.
Moody’s also mentions increasing steel imports, which rose 15% to 35 million tons in 2017, “on widening spreads, improved energy sector dynamics and a rise in imports ahead of the outcome of an investigation by the Commerce Department into national security implications of steel imports, known as a Section 232 probe.”
“The outcome from the Section 232 investigation remains uncertain, but we expect continued pricing support from current tariffs and ongoing circumvention and trade cases.”
The US Department of Commerce has proposed hefty tariffs on imports of Chinese aluminium and steel, based on national security considerations. But on Saturday China vowed to strike back if the 24% tariff on steel imports and at least 7.7% on aluminum imports – or higher tariffs on steel and aluminum from 12 countries including China – by limiting imports of American agricultural products.
According to the US Census Bureau, China exported about 740,000 tonnes of steel products to the US last year, around 6% less than 2016, reported the South China Morning Post.
Moody’s pointed out that thermal coal prices are likely to strengthen this year, and US metallurgical coal producers are benefitting from higher prices. It expects met-coal prices to swing from $95 to $145 a tonne. However the investor service couldn’t escape the fact that US coal will continue to decline in favour of cheaper natural gas, although it pointed out that the United States still generates 30% of its electricity from coal.
